Panthers vs. Oilers: Stanley Cup Final Rematch Sparks Split Predictions

For the second straight year, the Florida Panthers and Edmonton Oilers face off in the Stanley Cup Final, a rematch of last season’s thrilling seven-game series won by Florida. NHL.com’s panel of 16 writers and editors is evenly divided, with eight favoring the Panthers to repeat as champions and eight backing the Oilers to exact revenge starting in June 2025. The Conn Smythe Trophy, awarded to the playoff MVP, sees Edmonton’s Connor McDavid as the favorite with seven votes, followed by Florida’s Aleksander Barkov and Sergei Bobrovsky with four each, and Leon Draisaitl with one.

A Rivalry Renewed

The 2024 Final saw Florida jump to a 3-0 lead before Edmonton battled back, forcing a Game 7 that ended in a 2-1 Panthers victory. This year, both teams return with enhanced rosters and lessons learned. Florida, seeking to cement a dynasty, added defenseman Seth Jones from Chicago for mobility and scoring, and forward Brad Marchand from Boston for depth and grit alongside star Matthew Tkachuk. Edmonton, driven by last year’s heartbreak, boasts a tighter defensive structure and relies on McDavid and Draisaitl’s offensive brilliance, though they face a setback with forward Zach Hyman sidelined by an upper-body injury.

NHL.com’s split predictions reflect the matchup’s intensity. Writers like Brian Compton and Nicholas J. Cotsonika pick Florida in six, citing their physical edge (812 playoff hits vs. Edmonton’s 648) and Bobrovsky’s superior goaltending (1.34 GAA, .944 save percentage since May 10). Others, like Tom Gulitti and Dan Rosen, favor Edmonton in six, pointing to McDavid’s hunger and the team’s improved depth, drawing parallels to the 2009 Penguins’ redemption against Detroit. The series, starting June 4 in Edmonton, promises a clash of styles: Florida’s relentless forecheck versus Edmonton’s high-octane offense.

Conn Smythe Contenders

The Conn Smythe race highlights the series’ star power. McDavid, last year’s winner despite the loss, earned seven votes for his playoff dominance (42 points in 2024) and recent 4 Nations Face-Off heroics. Writers like Bill Price and Derek Van Diest see him as the best player on the planet, capable of carrying Edmonton to victory. Barkov, Florida’s captain, garnered four votes for his two-way mastery, with Mike G. Morreale noting his shutdown role against McDavid. Bobrovsky, also with four votes, is praised by William Douglas for elevating his game (7-2, two shutouts), potentially outdueling Edmonton’s Stuart Skinner (6-2, three shutouts). Draisaitl, with one vote from Amalie Benjamin, is a dark horse for his clutch scoring.

Team Dynamics and Stakes

Florida’s playoff run showcased resilience, rallying from a 2-0 deficit against Toronto and dominating Carolina in the Eastern Conference Final. Their depth, with 19 of 22 skaters scoring goals, and additions like Jones and Marchand make them a formidable unit. Edmonton, meanwhile, steamrolled the Western Conference, dispatching the Kings, Golden Knights, and Stars with a 42-26 even-strength scoring edge. Despite Hyman’s absence, Edmonton’s home-ice advantage at Rogers Place could prove pivotal, as Dave Stubbs envisions a raucous Canadian celebration 32 years after the Cup last resided north of the border.

A Historic Rematch

This Final marks only the second time since 1984 that the same teams have met in consecutive Stanley Cup Finals (following the Islanders-Oilers in 1983-84).

Source: article by nhl.com, published May 31, 2025.

Achieve More With VSA: Boost your skills with world-class coaches for just $29/hour. Perfect for skaters, hockey players, dancers, and athletes, VSA offers personalized training 24/7, 365 days a year, anywhere in the world.

By Vitalina Andrushchenko, Staff Writer